Google Podcasts
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Buzzsprout
YouTubeThe AUM Playbook Is Dying — And Your Advisor Knows It
Happy holidays. Now let’s talk about the thing people avoid at the dinner table: your money plan might be built on an outdated system—and nobody wants to say it out loud.
This episode with Shana Orczyk Sissel wasn’t just a “guest interview.” That’s family. That’s someone I trust to tell the truth even when it makes the industry uncomfortable.
And the truth is this: most advisors are working from the same playbook. Same framework. Same talking points. Same portfolios. Same “don’t worry about that” energy when you ask about anything outside the standard box.
Meanwhile, the market is doing what it does, clients are anxious, and real life keeps demanding decisions—not theories.
So here’s the episode in plain English.
The “Old Normal” Isn’t Coming Back
Shana brought up a story that should make every advisor sit up straight:
A young advisor leaves a firm, starts from zero, and ends up landing a $25M client opportunity.
Not because he had some secret product.
Not because he had the “best” portfolio.
Because he did what most people refuse to do:
He asked better questions.
He built a better conversation.
He brought options that didn’t look like the same cookie-cutter model everyone else pitched.
That’s it.
And that’s the bar now.
The BS We’re Fed: Comfort Talk Disguised as Strategy
Here’s the fluff people get sold:
“Just pick a model and stay the course.”
“Keep it simple. Don’t overthink it.”
“Alternatives are only for the ultra-wealthy.”
“Crypto is a scam.”
“The AUM model is the only real way to do advice.”
Some of that is well-intended. A lot of it is industry comfort—not client-centered planning.
Because the problem isn’t that the basics are wrong.
The problem is that “the basics” have become a shield for advisors who don’t want to evolve… and a sleep aid for clients who want to avoid hard conversations.
And I’m not judging that. I’m calling it what it is.
No BS Reality: Planning Wins. Then Tools Matter.
Let’s clean this up.
1) Most portfolios are the same—so stop pretending that’s “value”
If every advisor you meet uses the same custodians, the same fund families, the same models, the same buzzwords…
Then the portfolio alone isn’t the product.
The plan is. The questions are. The decisions are.
If your advisor can’t clearly explain how their process is different, you’re not buying advice—you’re buying a brand.
2) Alternatives aren’t a flex. They’re a tool—when used correctly.
Shana talked about alternatives as a way for advisors to differentiate—but only if they actually know the client.
Stuff like private credit and direct lending can play a role in a portfolio, depending on goals, liquidity needs, risk tolerance, and timeline.
But here’s the catch:
If you don’t have real discovery, alternatives become a shiny object.
If you don’t talk liquidity, lockups, and risk clearly, alternatives become a mess.
If you don’t understand what problem the client is trying to solve, alternatives become a sales pitch.
Alternatives aren’t “good” or “bad.”
They’re specific.
And specificity requires planning.
3) Advice 2030: the future isn’t AUM worship
This was one of the strongest points in the conversation:
The future of advice is moving away from pure AUM-based value.
Why?
Because the big custodians and platforms keep offering more “managed solutions.” More automation. More models. More tools.
So if an advisor’s value proposition is basically “I manage your investments”…
That’s a race to the bottom.
What people actually pay for—now and in the future—is:
decision support
behavior + accountability
strategy under stress
clarity when life changes
help making big moves without blowing up the plan
That’s real advice. That’s the job.
4) Crypto isn’t the point. The answer is.
This is where people get emotional—and where I get blunt.
You don’t have to love crypto.
You don’t have to own crypto.
You don’t have to recommend crypto.
But if your advisor’s entire viewpoint is: “It’s a scam.”
That’s not wisdom. That’s avoidance.
A qualified professional should be able to say:
why it doesn’t fit your plan
what risks matter most
what role (if any) it could play
what guardrails they’d use if you insisted
how they think about it relative to your goals
If they can’t articulate that, you’re not dealing with expertise. You’re dealing with fear dressed up as certainty.
Do This Next: The Questions That Expose the Truth
If you’re a client, ask your advisor these questions
Don’t ask to be nice. Ask to get clarity.
“What are we building this plan to do for my life?”
If the answer is only “retirement,” that’s lazy. Retirement is not a plan. It’s a vague destination.“What do you do that I can’t do with a brokerage app?”
If they can’t answer this cleanly, you’re paying for convenience—not strategy.“How do you think about alternatives like private credit?”
You’re listening for: goals, liquidity, risk, sizing, due diligence—not hype.“What’s your stance on crypto—and why?”
Not “do you like it?”
Why.
Make them explain.“When markets get ugly, what’s your process?”
If they don’t have a process, you’re about to learn the hard way.
If you’re an advisor, here’s your wake-up call
If you want to stay relevant, do these things—now:
Stop hiding behind “models.” Get better at discovery and real planning conversations.
Learn enough about alts and crypto to speak intelligently. Not to sell—so you don’t sound behind.
Build a compliance-friendly stance. “I don’t like it” is not a stance.
Create value that isn’t tied to AUM. Coaching, decisions, planning, life transitions.
Show up where clients actually are. If your whole business hides from modern conversations, you will get passed.